What happens when former Wall Street Journal reporter Asra Nomani returns to her hometown in West Virginia to find the mosque taken over by men she considers extremists.

Working in Pakistan after September 11, 2001, former Wall Street Journal reporter Asra Nomani faced a double shock: a surprise pregnancy and abandonment by the Pakistani man she thought would be her husband, then the murder of her dear friend Daniel Pearl at the hands of Muslim extremists. Still reeling, and with a son to raise, she returned to her hometown in West Virginia to find that the mosque had been taken over by men she saw as extremists. This documentary chronicles what happens when she decides to fight back - angering even the mosque's moderates. As the film unfolds, it tells a story of competing paths to social change, American identity and the nature of religion itself.